NATO once served a valid purpose and did so admirably. That purpose, however, is long gone and with
it NATO’s reason for existence or, at least, the US’ reason for remaining a
member of NATO. Unfortunately, the mere
mention of the faintest possibility of the US exiting NATO seems to trigger
angst and panic among so many observers in Europe and the US.
Panic among European observers is especially ironic given
that so many in Europe despise the US to begin with and work to actively
undermine and obstruct any US action or desire.
Let’s examine some of the arguments against the US pulling
out of NATO.
Isolation.
Many seem to feel that pulling out of NATO would automatically lead to
the US being isolationists on the world stage.
This is ridiculous. Aside from
erasing our name from a piece of paper, we’re just talking about removing our
military presence from Europe. We would
still have extensive and intimate financial, trade, cultural, and scientific
interactions.
Russian Threat.
This argument has been forever laid to rest by the Ukraine war. If a single, small country with almost no
military to begin the war and a population a quarter the size of Russia can
fight Russia to a standstill, albeit with significant munitions resupply help
from the West, then the Russian threat is overblown to the point of
irrelevance.
Political Balance.
Some suggest that the US presence balances political and territorial
ambitions among the European countries as if our absence from NATO would
trigger all out wars between European countries. This seems patently absurd if for no other
reason than the European countries don’t have much in the way of extensive or
effective militaries, as evidence by their very low defense expenditure levels
and nearly non-existent munitions inventories (remember Libya?)!
Mutual Military Support. The contention is that the US would lose the
military cooperation and support of European countries and access to
bases. Well, any country can assist the
US at any time and in any way they choose without the US needing to be part of
NATO. The reality, however, is that all
too often European countries already refuse to assist the US militarily. Overflight permissions have been refused
during US actions and foreign ships have pulled out of US naval task forces
when the possibility of US action has arisen.
Sometimes foreign countries assist us and sometimes they don’t. They have their political objectives and we
have ours. Short of invoking Article 5
of the NATO agreement, nothing would change the degree of cooperation with the
US.
Defense of Europe.
Some seem to think that if the US is not a member of NATO, that
precludes the US from helping to defend Europe.
This is absurd. If Europe is
threatened, the US will most certainly step in to help, treaty or no
treaty. It’s in our best interest.
Options
An option, for those too queasy about the US formally
pulling out of NATO, is that the US could simply pull out of Europe while
remaining a member of NATO. Nothing that
I’m aware of obligates us to be physically present on the continent. This would allow all the resources currently
devoted to Europe to be redirected at the real threat which is China.
Another option would be to use US withdrawal from NATO as a
major bargaining chip in a Ukraine-Russia peace settlement. For example, the US might agree to withdraw
from NATO if Russia returns Crimea and returns to pre-war borders and Ukraine
is granted NATO membership.
Conclusion
In summary, there is no valid argument for the US remaining
in NATO and every reason for the US to leave NATO. The world faces an extreme threat from China
and US resources need to be focused on that threat not babysitting a Europe
that faces no realistic threat. It is
past time for Europe to stand on its own.
It's not so much an issue that we are part of NATO, but the billions of dollars wasted each year on unneeded city-bases over there. Most should be turned over to host nations to operate for visiting American units and all families returned home. I did a short mini-doc about this issue a few years back:
ReplyDeletehttps://youtu.be/RtKcOzc0b-A?t=22
G2mil